[Featured Image description: Book cover of ‘Real Cowboys,’ by Hoefler & Bean.]
[Following Image Descriptions: All images in this post are the book covers discussed by the preceding text.]
It’s up to us to teach our boys about enthusiastic consent and the gray areas that put girls and women in danger. Below, we discuss how to educate our sons on respecting the agency and safety of both themselves and others.
Trigger warning for general discussions on rape culture and sexual harassment.
Parents of sons, we need to talk
Look around at all those little girls in your son’s school playground. Those girls whose names you know, who go to school with your boys. The fierce ones, the shy ones, the messy ones, and that one with her shoes on the wrong feet.
Every single one of those girls will be sexually assaulted or harassed before she’s 20.
Every. Single. One.
RAINN’s 1 in 6 women experiencing ‘rape or attempted rape’ statistic doesn’t count unreported assaults. Nor does it count slaps on the ass while waitressing. It doesn’t include being followed home on a dark night. It doesn’t include the lovers and friends guilting them into sex even when they don’t want it. It doesn’t include rape threats for being a female gamer/writer/zookeeper/anything.
This doesn’t count the 1 in 33 men and boys who report sexual assault, and the many more who don’t feel safe enough to do so.
This is our normal. This is the rape culture we perpetuate when we let toxic masculinity become someone else’s problem.
Mistake #1: Believing our perfect sons are incapable of bad choices
Victims don’t grow up in a vacuum. If they are being attacked – who is attacking them?
Our SONS. My sons, and yours – and many of our daughters. You know – those kids we’re raising to be so polite and respectful.
If you hear a quiet voice in the back of your head saying ‘Except not my son, he would never…’ that’s an example of embedded rape culture – the systemic, invisible influences we promote when we ignore what’s wrong in our society.
Our kids can be precious, wonderful, and lovely, and they can still be capable of doing stupid, awful, entitled, ignorant, and even violent things.
Mistake #2: Thinking ‘politeness’ is the same thing as ‘respect’
When the boys were tiny, my (male) partner argued, “I think we can just raise them to be decent humans, and then they will naturally treat women with respect and not rape them.”
NOPE. We teach our sons not to rape people…by teaching them not to rape people.
Parents of sons are not excused from the uncomfortable conversation of consent.
Parents of daughters don’t have the luxury of skipping uncomfortable conversations. This conversation was not a choice for my mother, as she armed me with a bottle of Baby Soft perfume to use as mace on my way to the school bus stop.
That’s the day I learned that femmes must expect attacks and remain vigilant. At all ages. Every day. Everywhere.
I was six.
Mistake #3: We Keep Going When They Say ‘Stop’
From birth, we’ve taught Q & R2 the importance of consent.
If they say to stop tickling them, we STOP.
If we are late for school and I’m wrestling R2 into his shirt and he says to stop, I STOP.
If I ask them for a hug them goodbye and they aren’t enthusiastic about it – I STOP.
And even when Q is in spoiled-whiny-turd mode, and I realize I’m gripping his arm as he fights to get away – I STOP.
I apologize. I verbally admit I did something wrong and I have the responsibility never to do it again.
We teach our children that there is no appointment important enough, no urge irresistible enough, no need of ours that surpasses their control over who touches them and how.
Mistake #4: Because I Say So.
We tell kids to respect our authority, not our reasoning.
When members request books on ‘respecting authority,’ it’s the only request I’m uncomfortable answering.
Teaching our kids to defer to the whims and directives of another human without question, simply because of their age, career, or social status, is how we build systems of oppression.
Respecting authority is mutually exclusive of respecting everyone.
Respecting everyone requires we approach differences with an open mind. We listen, we aim for compassion and understanding. We treat others how we’d like to be treated, and we respect the boundaries and reasonable wishes of others, while respecting our own.
Respecting authority, however, means we apply this kindness to our peers and those we have power over – but we must take it to a higher level for those above us. If we respected everyone, there would be no need to designate bonus respect for those in power.
Respecting authority is an act of submission and subjugation.
‘Respecting authority’ removes our agency and ability to question problematic action. It compels us to remain silent and not step out of line. We must respect our elders – even when they abuse us. We must respect our teachers even when they humiliate us. We must respect our employers even when they exploit us. We must respect our customers even when they trample us. We must respect our mentors even when they assault us. We must respect our breadwinners even when trap us. We must respect our police officers even when they murder us. We must respect our owners even as they beat us. We must respect our government even when they kidnap us.
When we put authorities on a pedestal, that leaves the rest of us as subordinates. Do you see where I’m going here? ‘Authority’ is just another word for our masters. This is authoritarian nonsense is the stuff of tyranny.
So no, I will not teach my boys to respect authority.
I teach my boys to respect people.
Mistake #5: Creating Loopholes
I’m tired. I’ve been working all day. I paid for everything. I got you this job. I never ask you for anything. You’re so inflexible. Are you sure you don’t want it?
Preventing assault is the responsibility of the attacker – never the victim. We don’t wait for our sons to use ‘code words’ when they want to stop rough-housing. It’s our responsibility as the tickler to remain vigilant for signs that we’re approaching a line.
‘No’ means no.
‘Well…okay’ means no.
Silence means no.
We hold power over our children. One day they will have power – over a romantic partner, apprentice, or child who can’t afford the economic, career, and social fallout of drawing a hard line in the sand.
If your victim has to scream “I MEAN IT,” you have already assaulted them.
There is no excuse for letting it get this far. Anything less than enthusiastic consent means STOP.
Victims can’t use ‘code words’ when unconscious. Victims can’t verbalize the reasons they feel uncomfortable when they’re young, isolated, and have nowhere else to go.
Many of us have been trained from early childhood to comply and consent to painful experiences or face dire consequences – like being put up for adoption, being institutionalized, or facing the rage of our attackers.
The responsibility preventing assault lies with the attacker. No exceptions.
Mistake #6: We Stay Silent
Do the work. Read one book each month and give your son the tools he needs to avoid being the victim or attacker in a sexual assault.
Captioned age ranges are for when my sons got ‘the gist’ of the story with discussion & alternative readings – most contain text for much older ages.
Practicing Consent At Home With Littles
‘I Like It When‘ was our best experience exercising ‘yes,’ ‘more,’ and ‘stop,’ before they were speaking (we used sign language).
While the book doesn’t explicitly address consent, each page contains text such as “I like it when you hug me tight.” Which inspired me to use the prompt: “Do you want me to hold your hand?” And then…whoa wait for it…I respected his decision. Sometimes he’d say ‘no’ – sometimes he’d say ‘yes!’ and sometimes he’d say nothing. We talked about why I won’t hug him if he doesn’t enthusiastically agree.
Plus bonus points for non-gendered penguins!
‘Tickle Monster‘ bumps the previous book up to some frantic tickling. This gave us a chance to model more advanced experiences, putting the onus on the tickler to check in with the ‘victim’ to make sure they still want it. This taught the boys that ‘Yes!’ means yes for now and it’s our responsibility to gauge comfort levels and reaffirm that consent before continuing. We make sure to emphasize the text “Are you sure you’re ready for what’s coming next?”
When we reverse roles, the boys inevitably ask “But whyyy can’t I tickle you?” Which opens discussion on why victims don’t have to justify a ‘no.’
We used ‘Kiss Tickle Cuddle, Hug‘ to model facial expressions (For many autistic folks, reading facial expressions is a learned, rather than inborn skill). I’ve had more enthusiasm about this one from allistic (non-autistic) kids, but it’s a valuable resource for everyone to label feelings and how that can be portrayed using eyebrow and mouth angles. For infants and toddlers, realistic illustrations and photography are necessary and valuable for teaching social skills, and the photography (which I am picky about) is fantastic and normalizes a wide range of ethnicities.
Similar to ‘I like it When,’ the text would read “Jayden makes a brave face, Jayden needs a snuggle,” and I’d ask my sons if they need a snuggle.
Building An Anti-Grooming Toolbox
I have a hate/need relationship with Julia Cook’s creepy, all-over-the-place books on social skills, but ‘Personal Space Camp‘ has been an invaluable resource for our family. One of my boy has impulse control issues and seeks touch – with an overwhelming compulsion to merge into friends like Luke Skywalker in a Tauntaun (He knows it’s not okay. We’re working on it.)
‘The Bubble Book‘ (links to PDF download) is simple and spectacular for covering the same ideas, but it’s an ebook and I’m too lazy to print things.
When the boys were little and I didn’t want to frighten them with the ‘stranger danger’ lectures I got in the 80’s, ‘Baby Dragon‘ was a gentle example of why they should listen to me when I tell them to stay put and not follow strangers – even if they seem helpful. It’s not a perfect book, but it worked for us as a primer, and helped us discuss procedures for if they ever get lost in public.
For years, BFL members asked for resources to protect their kids from grooming, especially around traditionally ‘safe’ adults. We settled for lots of mediocre, vague books like ‘Your Body Belongs To You‘ before I finally stumbled upon ‘That Uh-oh Feeling.’ (You’re going to notice a lot of books illustrated by Qin Leng on BFL, and that is because her books are amazing.)
Claire can’t quite explain what makes her feel so uncomfortable. Cole & Leng don’t try to portray the coach as a ‘bad guy’ – he’s friendly and approachable. If kids are always looking out for ‘bad guys,’ overt abuse, and strangers, they might fail to report things until it’s too late
What I love most about ‘That Uh-Oh Feeling‘ is that both Claire’s friends and mother believe her. If we want our kids to come to us before things go to far, they need to trust that we will take them seriously, and this book models proper behavior for both victims, peers and adults.
Modeling Non-Toxic Masculinity
If we want to prevent male aggression, we need to stop shaming our men and boys when they show emotion, overwhelm, and even weakness. Giving them healthy outlets for human reactions is how we prevent toxic masculinity before it boils over into an active shooter situation.
‘Tough Guys‘ is perfect for kids enamored with super-heroes and great feats of strength. While I would have preferred some variation, it means something to see strong, capable men who are willing to cry and vent there feelings in a healthy way.
‘Real Cowboys’ is deceptively simple and utterly stunning. Rough, tough, strong and powerful cowboys (who can also be cowgirls, and any race) are charged with protecting and nurturing others. They feel loneliness, sadness, and often need help. This book is magic – stories like this are what we need to tie the bravado of the ‘American Man’ into the responsibility, kindness, and vulnerability our fathers and grandfathers were never allowed to show.
‘Flare‘ is a simple early reader with a deceptively complex story. When Flare the phoenix is born, the Sun, Cloud, and Wind are alarmed to see he doesn’t cry. With some help, he eventually learns how his tears are necessary and valuable. (Seriously – it’s science.)
Before Q entered kindergarten, he informed me that 5-year-olds are not allowed to cry. I don’t know where he got this idea, but reading ‘Different Dragon‘ (not pictured) sorted out that nonsense right away. The storytelling is a bit messy and it could use some editing, but lines like this make it worth it: “It’s a lot of pressure to be fierce all the time. All that roaring and gnashing of teeth and snorting fire. It’s a lot of work to scare people and be so mean. And nobody ever wants a dragon to be funny or sad or just regular.”
Bonus points for normalizing gay parents (two moms).
Recognizing Girls Are People
If over half your books feature male-only protagonists, we have a problem, and not being able to find kick-ass girls is not an excuse. There are thousands.
Not all girl-centered books are created equal, and some do subtle, violent harm. Beware any story that features a strong female protagonist with the clause that she’s the exception to the rule and ‘not like the other girls.’ (Examples: ‘Violet the Pilot,’ ‘I Am Lucille Ball,’ and like 90% of what you can find on A Mighty Girl – which boasts ‘the largest collection of books and movies’ specifically because they include anything, even if it’s harmful). Throwing other women under the bus to highlight a single character reinforces the idea that girls have to be ‘like boys’ to make a valuable contribution to the world. That’s just the obviously misogynistic BS.
Both girls and boys (and non-binary kids) should read an equal mix of protagonists as powerful, vulnerable, complex protagonists that don’t conform to narrow gender roles. If we want men to stop treating women as objects, we need to teach our sons that girls are people just like them, and what matters to girls – whether it’s tutus, robots, or chemistry – matters.
‘Little Robot‘ is our favorite graphic novel here at Bumblebee Hollow. With minimal text, both my boys could ‘read’ it independently by age 3, which gives me the occasional precious break. In this story of a little girl of color befriending a robot, she experiences a complex range of emotions – from jealousy, bravery, and fear to joy and curiosity. Bonus points because she’s a handy engineer.
‘Ladybug Girl’ highlights universal little-kid problems with a female protagonist. We need more books like this – with boys and girls cooperating as equals.
The ‘Princess In Black‘ series of chapter books is just witty enough to keep me entertained when the boys ask me to read them over, and over, and over. This super-hero who is into ‘girly-girl’ things like ponies and princess parties shows kids that being traditionally feminine is not mutually exclusive to being a kick-ass monster fighter.
Model Responsible, Compassionate, and Disciplined Masculinity
I want to list ‘Last Stop On Market Street‘ (not pictured) because it’s a spectacular book on compassion and kind action, but since it’s the boy’s grandmother who initiates kind action, I’ll save it for another day. Right now, let’s focus on stories where the boys themselves direct the action and model good decisions on their own.
‘Invisible Boy‘ gets thrown around in lists about compassion and empathy. It’s okay, but problematic. I list it here specifically because I’m sick of this being the gold standard for empathy.
Reason #1 – There is no empathy modeled in the book, just two kids being baseline decent human beings while the rest of the class are asshats. Reason #2 – It’s full of stereotypes (nerd has glasses and no one picks him for sports, asian kid, because chopsticks). Reason #3 – The invisible boy earns friendship with kind actions, and they are immediately reciprocated. Kindness is not transactional. Books like this encourage kids with social disabilities to ‘earn’ friendship. Making friends when you are socially awkward doesn’t actually work like that and stories like this teach neurodivergent/awkward kids it’s our fault we’re ignored and bullied. For our kids who do not have a social disability, we should teach them to be kind to kids because they are human, not because they were kind to us when no one else was. WE CAN DO BETTER.
Faith McNulty’s thing is the interaction of fragile creatures from nature thrust into the world of man, relying on the compassion of powerful, conflicted humans to not squish them. I like these books a lot. Although irrelevant to boys behaving nicely, ‘The Lady And The Spider,’ (not pictured) is slow-paced and pensive, but holds up surprisingly well as a mild suspense-thriller for even young toddlers. For this list, ‘Mouse And Tim‘ is the perfect story to illustrate how we have to make the right (compassionate, selfless) choices when we are the ones who hold dominion over those with less. It’s the only book that left my loud and boisterous then-4-year-old into a deep, bittersweet, quiet contemplation after reading.
‘How To Heal A Broken Wing‘ highlights the importance of paying attention and going above-and-beyond what is expected of us. When the city ignores a hurt pigeon lying in the street, only one boy stops to care. He doesn’t have to spend weeks nurturing it back to health, but he decides to make it his responsibility.
Kindness is a muscle, friends. Work it.
Avoid These Books – Identifying Problematic Behavior
We need to stop reading stories like these to our kids immediately.
When I first started reading with my kids, I bought a copy of ‘A Visitor For Bear‘ because it was a cute, silly story. Only recently, after finding it lost deep in our bookshelves, do I realize this is the type of book I’d put unequivocally in the ‘NOPE’ list today – there is no way I’d read this to my boys after what I’ve learned over the years.
Mouse wants to be Bear’s friend. He keeps sneaking into Bear’s house. Bear says ‘no.’ Mouse apologizes, leaves, and shows up again. Bear shouts ‘NO.’… Repeat. Eventually, Mouse wears Bear down, and they become best friends.
After reading thousands of animal-protagonist books, I’m starting to see through to the metaphored messages we teach our children. No matter whether Bear is male or a bear or a human or the larger and stronger animal or a boss or a king – his ‘NO’ counts. He shouldn’t have to repeat it. He shouldn’t have to justify it. We should not see him broken down, we should not romanticize harassment.
Being less savvy with facial expressions as my allistic friends, I recommended ‘Hug Machine‘ years ago until long-time BFL’er Amanda L. pointed out that some of the Hug Machine’s targets looked uncomfortable with his affections. Not once does he ask permission, he just goes around groping people. As adorable as the story is, it’s a hard pass.
As an autistic woman, I hate ‘My Brother Charlie‘ with the heat of a thousand suns (hyperbole!) but for now, let’s just look at the cover. Look at it. Does he want that hug? NO HE DOES NOT. Back off, jerks! Charlie does not deserve your abuse. Seriously, I haaaaaate this violent, discriminatory, ableist crap book soooo much. Everyone involved should be ashamed of themselves.
In ‘Mud Puddle,’ a sentient mud puddle repeatedly attacks a young girl, violating her personal space, clothing, and body and forcing her mother to spend the day repeatedly washing her to get clean again. If she didn’t want to get dirty, she shouldn’t have left the house, amirite?! My 5yo found it hilarious. I did not.
‘You Will Be My Friend‘ is a cross between ‘Hug Machine’ and ‘A Visitor For Bear.’ Lucy chases down and physically assaults various animals until one of them likes the way she behaves. I totally identified with the Lucy – this was my experience as an autistic kid! Insipid stories like these tell us assault is okay if the attacker is a girl. I know better now – and I’m sorry.
‘The Bad Mood And The Stick’ not only teaches kids that we can’t just get out of a bad mood – we have to foist it off on someone else. That’s not even the terrible part! The terrible part is when a white man takes his pants off in the workplace of a black woman even though she protests and explicitly tells him not to. This delights her so much, they get married. What the actual fuck. Oh wait, I forgot Lemony Snickett has a history of unacceptable behavior toward black women.
Show Appreciated Snuggles
And no – I’m not some radical feminist monster who is against hugs. Just unwanted ones. If you’re looking for a cute alternative to ‘Hug Machine,’ try ‘Hug Time,’ which features hugs so in-demand, a whale leaps out of the water for them. (I could be wrong, but the main character’s best friend looks surprised by a hug, but not uncomfortable). Also check out ‘Hug Me,’ about a cactus that wants hugs and manages to keep his prickles to himself until he finds someone who wants them. Imagine that!
If you want a story like ‘You Will Be My Friend’ without the home invasion and assault, try ‘Elwood Bigfoot,’ which was so sweet it made me cry a little, and both boys rejoiced at the ending.
If you want to understand why ‘My Brother Charlie’ makes me so $%*&^#@ angry, read ‘Why Johnny Doesn’t Flap‘ to get an idea of what it feels like to be talked about like you’re a burden on society whose family will only love you when you conform in uncomfortable, distressing ways. Plus unlike ‘My Brother Charlie,’ it’s not endorsed by a hate group that advocates for the isolation & elimination of neurodiverse people. But maybe don’t leave ‘Why Johnny Doesn’t Flap’ around for your non-autistic kids to find, because it will make them feel like crap.
Tomorrow’s women can live without fear of sexual assault
When my grandmother was born over 80 years ago, over 2 out of every 25 children died before they reached age 5 – it was common.
Today, the death of a child is so rare and unexpected, it shakes entire communities. What was normal for my great-grandparents is unimaginable for me.
This means the bigotry and violence we live with today – the fear women live with now – could be unimaginable for my sons classmates. If we speak up, those little girls will be able to walk down the street, go to school, and live in safety without ever being sexually assaulted.
I can’t even imagine that – but I can hope.
Parents of sons – go to the library and read just one of these books a month. It’s our duty to build a safe future for tomorrow’s women.